I watched my maternal grandfather in the next room as he gripped his cane and struggled to get out of his chair. My grandmother Esther (“Mormor” to us, since she was Swedish) gave me a sad smile and quietly said, “I see pity in your eyes.”
She was probably right. I was 20 years old and in the prime of life. Papa had always been something of a legend to us grandkids. He was warm and kind to us but also quite reserved, and much of what we knew about him was second-hand. Mormor’s wonderful bedtime stories included proud tales of our grandfather’s abilities and achievements. It seemed there was nothing he couldn’t do, and to see him so debilitated by a paralyzing illness seemed tragically unfair.
Born in 1904 in a small town in coastal northern California, Carl McDonald had left home at age 13 and lived with an Indian tribe, commuting to elementary school in a canoe. He spent his whole life working and learning. During high school he lived in a shack he built for himself and worked on farms and in a barrel factory. While earning a teacher’s credential at Humboldt State Teacher’s College, he did hazardous work building railroad trestles and formed a dance band, having learned to play the saxophone, banjo, and violin. Somehow he found time to court Esther Holmgren, marrying her in 1925.
As a teacher and later a principal he would supplement his income fishing in the ocean with his good friend Cliff, using a 16 foot wooden boat they had built. Carl built a cabin and three houses for his family, and learned how to overhaul car engines so he could keep his teenaged kids’ jalopies running. He thought up highly effective – and amusing – disciplinary measures for misbehaving students. Late in his career he completed a master’s degree program, such was his dedication to his work. In retirement he hunted, gardened, formed another dance band, and traveled to Sweden with Mormor. In everything he did, it seemed that Papa had been in charge.
He handled the limitations and indignities of his illness bravely, but it hurt me to see those capable hands no longer able to do the things that his mind knew how to do. After Esther died in 1988, Carl spent his last five years in an assisted-living community near my parents’ home, and it seemed to me that he was largely waiting to join Esther in the old cemetery in her coastal hometown of Fortuna.
Life sometimes has a way of evening things up, inflicting the worst disabilities on those, such as Lou Gehrig and Stephen Hawking, who have accomplished much in other areas or other times and can live out their lives with no regrets. Papa had certainly done more than enough for one well-lived life. However, while going through some memorabilia with my mother recently, I found one pleasant little surprise: a certificate of appreciation from the assisted living facility for Carl’s participation in their security patrol. It seemed that even then he hadn’t given up on accomplishing things and taking charge.
Author’s note: more tales from Carl and Esther’s life can be found at my sister’s excellent blog site, Fooleryland.com, under the category “The Mormor Stories” and, coming soon, “The Papa Stories” (title TBD).





























